Spooky Season is HERE!
Utah's favorite hand-frosted sugar cookies just got spooky!
Soft vanilla sugar cookies + our signature cream cheese frosting. Available for preorder, same-day pickup & local delivery.
"The absolute best sugar cookies I've ever had. The frosting isn't too sweet, it's perfect!"
—Sarah M., Verified Customer
YOUR COOKIE YOUR WAY
Two ways to go custom
Custom Printed Cookies: your photo, logo or artwork printed on our cream cheese frosted cookies. From $30 per dozen. Order at least 2 days ahead.
Custom Hand-Frosted Cookies: your theme and designs, hand-frosted by our decorators on BIG cookies. From $56 per dozen. Order at least 1 week ahead.
Want a featured design with a name or your colors? Add lettering or color changes right on any featured cookie.
We Love Events
Catering
From cozy get-togethers to big-time celebrations — we LOVE catering events! Whether you’re planning a wedding, hosting a baby or bridal shower, coordinating a church activity, or organizing a corporate lunch, we’re ready to bring the sweet.
Our cookies have shown up everywhere — from Friday office treats to elegant dessert tables… even for The Utah Jazz (yep, we went there!). Each order is made fresh, fully customizable, and crafted to match the tone and theme of your event.
No matter the size or setting, we’ll help you make it memorable — one sugar cookie at a time.
What Our Customers Say About Us
Shop by collection
Baby Themed Sugar Cookies
Baby Themed Sugar Cookies
Frequently asked questions
What makes The Sugar Coated Sisters cookies different?
Our cookies are soft vanilla sugar cookies topped with our signature cream cheese frosting — the perfect mix of cute AND delicious. Every cookie is made fresh and designed to fit your event, theme, or celebration. We specialize in customizable cookies for birthdays, baby showers, weddings, corporate events, church events, holidays, and more.
How far in advance should I place my custom cookie order?
Featured cookies and custom printed cookies need at least 2 days notice. Custom hand-frosted cookies need at least 1 week notice, and if your order includes any hand-frosted cookies, the 1 week applies to the whole order. The pickup and delivery calendar only shows dates that work for what is in your cart. During busy seasons and holidays, earlier is always better.
Do you offer same-day cookie pickup?
Yes! We offer same-day sugar cookie pickup through our “Daily Claim.” Each day we make a few extra cookies and post them to our Daily Claim, available for immediate pickup. Quantities are limited and sold first come, first served. It’s perfect for last-minute gifts, parties, office treats, or sugar cravings.
Where are your pickup locations?
We offer pickup locations throughout Salt Lake County and Davis County, including Draper, Holladay, The Gateway, Woods Cross, Bountiful, and Layton. Some locations also receive fresh cookie deliveries daily.
Can I fully customize my cookies?
Absolutely! You have three options:
Featured cookies: add lettering ($5 per order) or color changes ($10 per order) to any featured design. Each fee is charged once per order, no matter how many featured items you personalize.
Custom printed cookies: upload your photo, logo or artwork. MINI printed $30/dozen (up to 2 images), BIG printed one image $45/dozen, BIG printed multiple images $55/dozen (up to 6 images).
Custom hand-frosted cookies: BIG cookies designed from scratch. $56/dozen for 3 designs, $64 for 4 designs, $72 for 6 designs. Share your theme, colors, details and inspiration photos right on the order form.
Questions? Text Abby at (385) 222-5756.
What events do you cater?
We cater all kinds of events including weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, birthdays, corporate events, church events, graduations, teacher appreciation gifts, holidays, and more. Whether you need a few dozen cookies or a large dessert table setup, we’d love to help make your event a show stopper.
What sizes and packaging options do you offer?
BIG sugar cookies: by the dozen
MINI sugar cookies: by the dozen
Party boxes: 6 BIG sugar cookies & 8 MINI sugar cookies
Party packs: 8 MINI sugar cookies
Party sleeves: 4 MINI sugar cookies
Custom hand-frosted cookies come in BIG dozens. Custom printed cookies come in MINI or BIG dozens.
Individually bagged cookies are $1 per cookie ($12 per dozen). Just check the box on the product page.
We can meet your event needs, our largest order to date has been 275 dozen sugar cookies! Each created and decorated by hand.
Do your cookies contain allergens?
Our cookies contain common allergens including wheat, dairy, eggs, and gluten. NO NUTS.
How should I store my cookies?
For the best taste and freshness, wrap your cookie boxes in saran wrap and put them in the fridge. They don't need to be wrapped if your cookies came in a clear package. Our cookies do freeze extremely well, and leftovers can be stored in the freezer to be used as late night snacks.
Avoid direct sunlight or heat. Our cookies stay soft and delicious for several days when properly stored.
Do you deliver cookies?
Yes! We currently offer delivery throughout Salt Lake County and Davis County, in addition to multiple pickup locations across Northern Utah. Delivery availability may vary depending on your order size and location.