The Sugar Coated Sisters

Vanilla sugar cookies with cream cheese frosting.

Order here

"The absolute best sugar cookies I've ever had. The frosting isn't too sweet, it's perfect!"

—Sarah M., Verified Customer

The Daily Claim

Need cookies today? Claim your same-day sugar cookie box for local pickup.

The Daily Claim is our way of making fresh cookies easier, faster, and more affordable for everyone.

Each day, we feature a limited selection of our cookies that are available for same-day pickup or quick ordering. Instead of needing to preorder, you can simply “claim” the cookies you want from that day’s lineup before they sell out.

Here’s how it works:

Fresh cookies are posted daily
Quantities are limited
First come, first served

Perfect for last-minute gifts, office treats, family desserts, or a personal sweet fix

New themes rotate regularly

Whether you’re celebrating something special or just need a little pick-me-up, The Daily Claim gives you access to fresh cookies without the wait.

✨ Check The Daily Claim for your favorites and enjoy before they’re gone!

The Daily Claim

Pick up locations throughout Salt Lake & Davis County

Draper, Holladay, The Gateway, Woods Cross, Bountiful & Layton.

Delivery: Davis County & Salt Lake County.

Order Here!

Shop by collection

Baby Themed Sugar Cookies

YOUR COOKIE YOUR WAY

Create your own designs with our Custom Sugar Cookies

With our Custom Sugar Cookie experience, you’re in charge of the sweetness! Choose your favorite type and quantity — from classic full-size sugar cookies to bite-sized minis — and customize everything from the shape to the theme. Whether you're planning a party, sending a thoughtful gift, or just treating yourself, we'll bring your vision to life in cookie form.

Big or small, round or heart-shaped, simple or fully decked out — if you can dream it, we can bake it.

Let’s get creative — your perfect cookie starts here.

Start Customizing Now

We Love Events

Catering

From cozy get-togethers to big-time celebrations — we LOVE catering events! Whether you’re planning a wedding, hosting a baby or bridal shower, coordinating a church activity, or organizing a corporate lunch, we’re ready to bring the sweet.

Our cookies have shown up everywhere — from Friday office treats to elegant dessert tables… even for The Utah Jazz (yep, we went there!). Each order is made fresh, fully customizable, and crafted to match the tone and theme of your event.

No matter the size or setting, we’ll help you make it memorable — one sugar cookie at a time.

What Our Customers Say About Us

So Cute And Fun

So cute and fun! But the most important part is they are delicious! Sometimes cute sugar cookies don’t taste very good! These are as delicious as they are cute! Will definitely order from them again!

Sharee N

Verified Purchase

Absolutely Amazing!

Absolutely amazing! They matched my theme perfectly and were a huge hit. But also so much more delicious than other cookies!

Kaylee D.

Verified Purchase

The Cookies Were Perfect

Everyone at our granddaughters blessing commented on how cute and good the cookies were. They were perfect!

Hillary C.

Verified Purchase

Cookies To Die For!

These cookies are to die for! They are the cutest and also taste incredible. I will be ordering again and again. Thank you!!

McKall N.

Verified Purchase

Deliciously Adorable!

The cookies were delicious, adorable, and arrived right on time. We couldn't be happier that we chose to celebrate a special day with the Sugar Coated Sisters. We will be return customers for sure!

Jen W.

Verified Purchase

Frequently asked questions

Our cookies are soft vanilla sugar cookies topped with our signature cream cheese frosting — the perfect mix of cute AND delicious. Every cookie is made fresh and designed to fit your event, theme, or celebration. We specialize in customizable cookies for birthdays, baby showers, weddings, corporate events, church events, holidays, and more.

We recommend ordering custom cookies as early as possible, especially during busy seasons and holidays. While we do our best to accommodate last-minute requests, earlier ordering gives us the best chance to fully customize your design and reserve your pickup date.

Yes! We offer same-day sugar cookie pickup through our “Daily Claim.” Each day we make a few extra cookies and post them to our Daily Claim, available for immediate pickup. Quantities are limited and sold first come, first served. It’s perfect for last-minute gifts, parties, office treats, or sugar cravings.

We offer pickup locations throughout Salt Lake County and Davis County, including Draper, Holladay, The Gateway, Woods Cross, Bountiful, and Layton. Some locations also receive fresh cookie deliveries daily.

Absolutely! We can customize shapes, colors, themes, lettering, logos, and designs to match your event. Simply choose your cookie size and quantity, then send us your inspiration photos, color palette, and theme ideas. Our decorating team will bring your vision to life.

We cater all kinds of events including weddings, bridal showers, baby showers, birthdays, corporate events, church events, graduations, teacher appreciation gifts, holidays, and more. Whether you need a few dozen cookies or a large dessert table setup, we’d love to help make your event a show stopper.

BIG sugar cookies: by the dozen

MINI sugar cookies:by the dozen

Party boxes: 6 BIG sugar cookies & 8 MINI sugar cookies

Party packs: 8 MINI sugar cookies

Party sleeves: 4 MINI sugar cookies

We can meet your event needs, our largest order to date has been 275 dozen sugar cookies! Each created and decorated by hand.

We also offer individually packaged cookies. for more info on this text Carson (385)222-5756

Our cookies contain common allergens including wheat, dairy, eggs, and gluten. NO NUTS.

For the best taste and freshness, wrap your cookie boxes in saran wrap and put them in the fridge. They don't need to be wrapped if your cookies came in a clear package. Our cookies do freeze extremely well, and leftovers can be stored in the freezer to be used as late night snacks.

Avoid direct sunlight or heat. Our cookies stay soft and delicious for several days when properly stored.

Yes! We currently offer delivery throughout Salt Lake County and Davis County, in addition to multiple pickup locations across Northern Utah. Delivery availability may vary depending on your order size and location.